The legal term “best interests” is a concept that comes up in almost all child-related areas of family law. When making essentially any decision on behalf of a child, the court is going to look at what is best for that child and allow that to guide their rulings. Some issues, like the idea that all parents should provide financial support for their children, are bright-line best interests concepts that have only one interpretation. There really isn’t anyone who would argue that a child doesn’t benefit from financial support from both of their parents. However, many child-related decisions are not so clear and straightforward, which is where the idea of “best interests” really comes into play in custody cases when trying to figure out how to divide up parenting time and decision-making between the parents.
Ideally, both parents will be equally involved in the child’s life — that is the standard under Illinois law and the preference of the judges. However, realistically, not all parents are fit to have equal parenting time or equal decision-making authority, and that is when best interests often come into consideration when deciding how to divide up the parents’ time and authority for the children. What Are the Best Interest Factors? There are a variety of factors that are taking into consideration when determining the best interests on the child, and those factors difference based on whether the judge is allocating parenting time and decision-making authority. Best Interest Factors for Decision-Making Responsibilities Here are the best interests factors that can be considered for decision-making responsibilities under Illinois law:
Best Interest Factors for Allocation of Parenting Time In Illinois, the best interests factors that the court can consider for the allocation of parenting time:
How Do You Show Best Interests of the Child? For both issues, best interests can be proven through evidence and testimony. Evidence can include all kinds of written communications and documents, as well as photos, videos, and the like. It can include the parents’ testimony as well as the testimony of experts like a Guardian ad Litem, therapists, doctors, and parenting evaluators, all of whom can provide information and opinions about the parents’ individual relationship with the child and whether there are concerns about the child spending time with one parent or allowing that parent to make decisions for the child. In some cases, evidence will show concerns for the child’s safety in the care of one parent, which is an issue that often comes into place when there are allegations of substance abuse, abuse, neglect, untreated mental illness, and so on. In these situations, the court may find that the parent is unable to safely care for the child and place restrictions on the parent’s parenting time and decision-making for the child to protect the child from emotional or physical harm. A best interests determination could also directly involve the child, though most parents, attorneys, and judges try to keep the children out of the litigation. However, in some instances the judge may feel compelled to speak with the child directly to get their opinions and input on their relationship with each parent. This is increasingly likely with older children, as they are deemed to have greater authority with the court in where they live and how much time they spend with each parent. Who Determines the Best Interests of the Child? The simple answer is that the judge determines what is in the best interests of the child, as the judge enters the order allocating parenting time and decision-making. However, the judge’s decision can be heavily influenced (though not always) by the opinions and findings of experts, like therapists and parenting evaluators. Judges often rely on those who have worked directly with the family but maintain the position of being a neutral third party, when making decisions about what is best for a child. What is Not in the Best Interests of the Child? First and foremost, it is not in the best interests of a child to be put into a situation where the child could suffer harm, abuse, or neglect due to the parent’s actions. Parents are expected to protect their children from exposure to or risk of harm. When they fail to do that, whether on purpose through abuse or inadvertently through negligence, they stand to lose time with and responsibility for their child even if the child is not injured. Likewise, failure to provide for a child’s basic needs like food, clothing, shelter, medical care, an education, and the like are considered to not be in a child’s best interests. If a parent fails to provide or facilitate these resources, they are generally as not acting in the child’s best interests. Interactions Between a Child’s Parents But perhaps the most common issue that comes up in family law cases when dealing with the issue of best interests is the parents’ interactions with each other regarding their children directly to their children. Parents who actively interfere with or discourage the child from having a healthy, loving relationship with the other parent, either by not allowing them to communicate or have time together or perhaps by disrespecting and disparaging the other parent in front of the child, are often considered to be engaging in alienation. This is severely looked down upon by judges. In some situations, if a parent heavily interferes with the other parent’s time and communications with the child(ren), the court may decide to award majority parenting time and decision-making to the other parents in recognition of the harm caused to a child when they are prevented from having a relationship with both parents. Unless the parents is actively abusive or a danger to the child, parents should be careful about placing limits or restrictions on the child’s ability to maintain a positive relationship with both parents, as that is considered one of the fundamental best interests of all children. THIS ARTICLE WAS PREVIOUSLY PUBLISHED AT: https://illinoislawforyou.com/blog/how-do-you-prove-the-best-interests-of-the-child/
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorArchives
August 2022
Categories |